• Home
    • Podcast Home
    • Newsletter Home
    • Front Page
  • Newsletter Search
  • Podcast Search
  • The Board
Menu
  • Home
    • Podcast Home
    • Newsletter Home
    • Front Page
  • Newsletter Search
  • Podcast Search
  • The Board
  • Home
    • Podcast Home
    • Newsletter Home
    • Front Page
  • Newsletter Search
  • Podcast Search
  • The Board
Menu
  • Home
    • Podcast Home
    • Newsletter Home
    • Front Page
  • Newsletter Search
  • Podcast Search
  • The Board
Home Dragon King
DragonKingKarl Classic Wrestling Show: The mystery of Barney Smith

DragonKingKarl Classic Wrestling Show: The mystery of Barney Smith

Karl Stern by Karl Stern
October 15, 2023
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

On this week’s DragonKingKarl Classic Wrestling Show, it’s another episode in my 1000 Hours series.

Hour 21 focuses on the mystery of Barney Smith.

While his current status of being alive or dead isn’t a mystery (he lived 150 years ago), the question is whether Col. James H. McLaughlin (seen above) killed him.

In the early 2000s when I first really dug into the pioneers of pro wrestling, I was led to believe that in a famous wrestling tournament in Detroit, MI, in 1870, McLaughlin wrestled Smith in the finals and Smith died the day after. There were many specific details to the incident told to me by a historian.

The problem is that over 20 years later and with access to all the major newspapers of the day, there doesn’t seem to be a shred of evidence to support it.

So what happened to Barney Smith?

(sub needed)

https://media001.f4wonline.com/dmdocuments/101523ks.mp3

Podcast: Play in new window | Download (Duration: 56:20 — 37.7MB)

F4W~!

Listen to this show and tons of other great shows for as little as $9.99 a month.
Plus the Wrestling Observer Newsletter!

Subscribe Now!

Already a F4W/WON subscriber? login to listen to this show.

Tags: Barney SmithCol. James McLaughlinDragon Kingpioneer erapodcasts
Karl Stern

Karl Stern

Next Post
Bryan & Vinny & Craig Show: AEW Collision with Danielson vs. Christian, plus weekly live Q&A!

Bryan & Vinny & Craig Show: AEW Collision with Danielson vs. Christian, plus weekly live Q&A!

Recommended.

December 15 2009 Wrestling Observer

December 15 2009 Wrestling Observer

December 15, 2009
Wrestling Observer Live: What WWE SummerSlam is missing, SmackDown recap

Wrestling Observer Live: What WWE SummerSlam is missing, SmackDown recap

June 19, 2023

Trending.

WOR: Backlash, McIntyre, Saudi and Punk, UFC results, more

WOR: Backlash, McIntyre, Saudi and Punk, UFC results, more

May 26, 2025
WOR: WWE cuts in detail, weekend TV, news!

WOR: WWE cuts in detail, weekend TV, news!

May 4, 2025
B&V&C: Retro Raw and Nitro from 19 years ago this week!

B&V&C: Retro Raw and Nitro from 19 years ago this week!

September 8, 2023
WOR: WWE releases, AAA & WWE, AEW’s residency

WOR: WWE releases, AAA & WWE, AEW’s residency

May 2, 2025
B&V&C: Retro Raw and Nitro from 19 years ago this week!

B&V&C: Retro Raw and Nitro from 19 years ago this week!

September 8, 2023
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Customer Service

© 2023 Figure Four Weekly, LLC. All Rights Reserved. Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy

Menu
  • Home
    • Podcast Home
    • Newsletter Home
    • Front Page
  • Newsletter Search
  • Podcast Search
  • The Board